Washington Square Tavern

Let's Eat by Kitty Kaufman

Here's my dilemma: If I tell you how great Washington Square Tavern is then we're all going to have to wait. So let's manage the logistics - we'll go early and sit at the communal table and you hang at the bar with your Martinelli Jackass Zin.

Friday night out. We got seated at once and you will too if you go early. Fried calamari with yuzu aioli arrived first sans garlic, tomato sauce, cherry peppers, and hot sauce. Fish fans know what a satisfying starter this is. We order it only when it's not Rhode Island style.

Bright mesclun and baby spinach salad, so fresh they must be growing it out back, with walnuts and citrus dressing was crunchy and tangy. Frisée salad comes with creamy goat cheese and golden beets, milder than and not as messy as red ones.

With the menu's American slant, the no-meat group can start with the PEI mussels. Carry on with roasted eggplant and spinach ravioli; roasted local cod and one of our evening's choices: local sea scallops. Huge and lightly cooked, they were plated with what we thought was sauce that turned out to be cauliflower puree. On the list of vegetables we know we should be eating but aren't, this preparation stands as a tribute to chef Chris Cronin's bent of less being more along with who knew? Cronin, late of Delux Café, also knows what to do with his gnocchi. He terms it simply parmesan gnocchi with sweet fennel sausage and San Marzano tomatoes and piles high tiny pillows with house made sausage and smooth tomato sauce.

The secret to Tavern's ongoing success may be what they don't do: no reservations, no take-out, no dessert and no valet parking. They keep the lights low and the music peppy, with servers who know the menu inside out.

See it on TripAdvisor

© April 19, 2012 for TripAdvisor.com

2013 © 2001-2013 all rights reserved * * Contact us for permission Send us a note * *